
Lakes in Custer County, Idaho
Photo: Redfish Lake and the Sawtooth Range, Idaho. HalcyonToast, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
LakeMonster tracks 26 lakes and reservoirs in Custer County, Idaho, with a combined recorded surface of about 4,152 acres. The largest, Redfish Lake, covers 1,531 acres and is also the most visited on LakeMonster. Fish species are listed for 12 of them, most often rainbow trout, cutthroat trout and brook trout. Each lake page shows water temperature, lake weather and wind, satellite imagery and a map, so you can compare lakes before you drive.
- Lakes
- 26
- Recorded surface
- 4,152
- acres of water
- Fish species
- 12
- listed across 12 lakes
- Boat ramps
- 2
- lakes with one on record
Map of lakes in Custer County, Idaho
Custer County, Idaho lakes by the numbers
Most visited on LakeMonster
- 1.Redfish Lake1,531 acres
- 2.Stanley Lake185 acres
- 3.Mackay Reservoir1,178 acres
- 4.Sawtooth Lake173 acres
- 5.Goat Lake44 acres
Largest by surface area
- 1.Redfish Lake1,531 acres
- 2.Mackay Reservoir1,178 acres
- 3.Yellow Belly Lake193 acres
- 4.Stanley Lake185 acres
- 5.Sawtooth Lake173 acres
Deepest on record
- 1.Sawtooth Lake114 ft
- 2.Goat Lake67 ft
- 3.Mackay Reservoir42 ft
- 4.Jimmy Smith Lake38 ft
- 5.Hell Roaring Lake37 ft
Highest elevation on record
- 1.Imogene Lake8,442 ft
- 2.Sawtooth Lake8,432 ft
- 3.Toxaway Lake8,333 ft
- 4.Toxaway Lake8,333 ft
- 5.Hell Roaring Lake7,415 ft
All 26 lakes in Custer County, Idaho
Showing 1–26 of 26 lakes
| Lake | Water temp |
|---|---|
| Redfish LakeStanley · Custer County1,531 acres5 fish species · Boat ramp, Camping | 46°FOct 30 |
| Stanley LakeStanley · Custer County185 acres4 fish species · Boat ramp, Motor boats | 50°FOct 30 |
| Mackay ReservoirMackay · Custer County1,178 acres42 ft deep · 5 fish species | 52°FOct 30 |
| Sawtooth LakeStanley · Custer County173 acres114 ft deep · 4 fish species · Fishing lake | 42°FOct 30 |
| Goat LakeStanley · Custer County44 acres67 ft deep · 3 fish species · Fishing lake | 48°FOct 30 |
| Little Redfish LakeStanley · Custer County67 acres10 ft deep · 3 fish species | 45°FOct 30 |
| Jimmy Smith LakeClayton · Custer County48 acres38 ft deep · 4 fish species · Fishing lake | 49°FOct 30 |
| Mosquito Flat ReservoirChallis · Custer County49 acres12 ft deep | 47°FOct 30 |
| Sullivan LakeClayton · Custer County40 acres37 ft deep · 8 fish species · Fishing lake | 43°FOct 30 |
| Imogene LakeSawtooth City · Custer County77 acres24 ft deep · 3 fish species | 44°FOct 30 |
| Toxaway LakeSawtooth City · Custer County121 acres30 ft deep · 3 fish species · Fishing lake | 44°FOct 30 |
| Yellow Belly LakeSawtooth City · Custer County193 acres34 ft deep | 46°FOct 30 |
| Hell Roaring LakeSawtooth City · Custer County57 acres37 ft deep · 3 fish species | 44°FOct 30 |
| Toxaway LakeSawtooth City · Custer County121 acres30 ft deep · 3 fish species · Fishing lake | 44°FOct 30 |
| Bayhorse LakeBayhorse · Custer County25 acres | 42°FOct 30 |
| Cape Horn Lake #1Stanley · Custer County41 acres | 48°FOct 30 |
| Farley LakeObsidian · Custer County33 acres | not recorded |
| Alpine LakeObsidian · Custer County28 acres | not recorded |
| Alpine LakeStanley · Custer County22 acres | not recorded |
| Cirque LakeObsidian · Custer County20 acres | not recorded |
| Betty LakeTriumph · Custer County19 acres | not recorded |
| Cove LakeObsedian · Custer County19 acres | not recorded |
| Horseshoe LakeCuster · Custer County19 acres | not recorded |
| Herd LakeChilly · Custer County17 acres | not recorded |
| Crater LakeTorreys · Custer County16 acres | not recorded |
| Buster LakeBayhorse · Custer County11 acres | not recorded |
Lakes in nearby counties
Questions about lakes in Custer County, Idaho
- How many lakes are in Custer County, Idaho?
- LakeMonster tracks 26 lakes and reservoirs in Custer County, Idaho. This counts the lakes LakeMonster follows, not every pond and water body.
- What is the largest lake in Custer County, Idaho?
- By recorded surface area, the largest lake in Custer County, Idaho on LakeMonster is Redfish Lake at 1,531 acres, followed by Mackay Reservoir (1,178 acres), Yellow Belly Lake (193 acres) and Stanley Lake (185 acres).
- What is the deepest lake in Custer County, Idaho?
- Of the lakes with a recorded maximum depth, the deepest is Sawtooth Lake at about 114 feet, followed by Goat Lake (67 ft), Mackay Reservoir (42 ft) and Jimmy Smith Lake (38 ft).
- What fish can you catch in Custer County, Idaho lakes?
- The species listed most often for Custer County, Idaho lakes on LakeMonster are rainbow trout (12 lakes), cutthroat trout (11 lakes), brook trout (10 lakes), mountain whitefish (5 lakes), smallmouth bass (2 lakes) and yellow perch (2 lakes). Species lists are available for 12 of the 26 lakes. Check state regulations and seasons before fishing.
- What are the most popular lakes in Custer County, Idaho?
- The most visited Custer County, Idaho lake pages on LakeMonster are Redfish Lake, Stanley Lake, Mackay Reservoir, Sawtooth Lake and Goat Lake.
- Which lakes in Custer County, Idaho have a boat ramp?
- LakeMonster has a boat ramp on record at 2 lakes in Custer County, Idaho, including Redfish Lake and Stanley Lake. Amenities are not recorded for every lake, so other lakes may have ramps too.
- Which lakes in Custer County, Idaho have camping?
- Camping is on record at 1 lake in Custer County, Idaho, including Redfish Lake. Amenities are not recorded for every lake.
- What is the highest lake in Custer County, Idaho?
- Of the lakes with a recorded elevation, the highest is Imogene Lake at about 8,442 feet above sea level, followed by Sawtooth Lake (8,432 ft) and Toxaway Lake (8,333 ft).
Keep exploring
This list is rebuilt every day from LakeMonster’s lake records. Newest lake data in Custer County, Idaho: . Sizes, depths and amenities are as recorded and are not available for every lake; water temperature readings show their own date.