
Lakes in Cattaraugus County, New York
Photo: Lake George, New York. Hayden Soloviev, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
LakeMonster tracks 7 lakes and reservoirs in Cattaraugus County, New York, with a combined recorded surface of about 912 acres. The largest is Quaker Lake (268 acres) and the most visited on LakeMonster is Lime Lake. Fish species are listed for 2 of them, most often black crappie, brown bullhead and largemouth bass. Each lake page shows water temperature, lake weather and wind, satellite imagery and a map, so you can compare lakes before you drive.
- Lakes
- 7
- Recorded surface
- 912
- acres of water
- Fish species
- 10
- listed across 2 lakes
Map of lakes in Cattaraugus County, New York
Cattaraugus County, New York lakes by the numbers
Most visited on LakeMonster
- 1.Lime Lake159 acres
- 2.Quaker Lake268 acres
- 3.Case Lake71 acres
- 4.Red House Lake110 acres
- 5.New Albion Lake45 acres
Largest by surface area
- 1.Quaker Lake268 acres
- 2.Lake Flavia225 acres
- 3.Lime Lake159 acres
- 4.Red House Lake110 acres
- 5.Case Lake71 acres
Deepest on record
- 1.Case Lake40 ft
- 2.Quaker Lake40 ft
- 3.Lime Lake38 ft
- 4.Red House Lake20 ft
- 5.New Albion Lake16 ft
All 7 lakes in Cattaraugus County, New York
Showing 1–7 of 7 lakes
| Lake | Water temp |
|---|---|
| Lime LakeMachias · Cattaraugus County159 acres38 ft deep · 9 fish species | 56°FOct 30 |
| Quaker LakeCold Spring · Cattaraugus County268 acres40 ft deep · 6 fish species | 56°FOct 30 |
| Case LakeFranklinville · Cattaraugus County71 acres40 ft deep | 56°FOct 30 |
| Red House LakeRed House · Cattaraugus County110 acres20 ft deep | 56°FOct 30 |
| New Albion LakeNew Albion · Cattaraugus County45 acres16 ft deep | 55°FOct 30 |
| Harwood LakeFarmersville · Cattaraugus County34 acres14 ft deep | 55°FOct 30 |
| Lake FlaviaSouth Dayton · Cattaraugus County225 acres | 58°FOct 30 |
Lakes in nearby counties
Questions about lakes in Cattaraugus County, New York
- How many lakes are in Cattaraugus County, New York?
- LakeMonster tracks 7 lakes and reservoirs in Cattaraugus County, New York. This counts the lakes LakeMonster follows, not every pond and water body.
- What is the largest lake in Cattaraugus County, New York?
- By recorded surface area, the largest lake in Cattaraugus County, New York on LakeMonster is Quaker Lake at 268 acres, followed by Lake Flavia (225 acres), Lime Lake (159 acres) and Red House Lake (110 acres).
- What is the deepest lake in Cattaraugus County, New York?
- Of the lakes with a recorded maximum depth, the deepest is Case Lake at about 40 feet, followed by Quaker Lake (40 ft), Lime Lake (38 ft) and Red House Lake (20 ft).
- What fish can you catch in Cattaraugus County, New York lakes?
- The species listed most often for Cattaraugus County, New York lakes on LakeMonster are black crappie (2 lakes), brown bullhead (2 lakes), largemouth bass (2 lakes), smallmouth bass (2 lakes), yellow perch (2 lakes) and bluegill (1 lake). Species lists are available for 2 of the 7 lakes. Check state regulations and seasons before fishing.
- What are the most popular lakes in Cattaraugus County, New York?
- The most visited Cattaraugus County, New York lake pages on LakeMonster are Lime Lake, Quaker Lake, Case Lake, Red House Lake and New Albion Lake.
Keep exploring
This list is rebuilt every day from LakeMonster’s lake records. Newest lake data in Cattaraugus County, New York: . Sizes, depths and amenities are as recorded and are not available for every lake; water temperature readings show their own date.