
Lakes in Herkimer County, New York
Photo: Lake George, New York. Hayden Soloviev, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
LakeMonster tracks 44 lakes and reservoirs in Herkimer County, New York, with a combined recorded surface of about 22,000 acres. The largest is Stillwater Reservoir (6,700 acres) and the most visited on LakeMonster is Fourth Lake. Fish species are listed for 10 of them, most often black crappie, bluegill and largemouth bass. Each lake page shows water temperature, lake weather and wind, satellite imagery and a map, so you can compare lakes before you drive.
- Lakes
- 44
- Recorded surface
- 22,000
- acres of water
- Fish species
- 17
- listed across 10 lakes
Map of lakes in Herkimer County, New York
Herkimer County, New York lakes by the numbers
Most visited on LakeMonster
- 1.Fourth Lake2,137 acres
- 2.Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)1,070 acres
- 3.Hinckley Reservoir2,880 acres
- 4.Stillwater Reservoir6,700 acres
- 5.Big Moose Lake1,242 acres
Largest by surface area
- 1.Stillwater Reservoir6,700 acres
- 2.Hinckley Reservoir2,880 acres
- 3.Fourth Lake2,137 acres
- 4.Big Moose Lake1,242 acres
- 5.Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)1,070 acres
Deepest on record
- 1.Honnedaga Lake124 ft
- 2.Little Moose Lake122 ft
- 3.North Lake96 ft
- 4.Fourth Lake85 ft
- 5.Sand Lake83 ft
All 44 lakes in Herkimer County, New York
Showing 1–44 of 44 lakes
| Lake | Water temp |
|---|---|
| Fourth LakeInlet · Herkimer County and Hamilton County2,137 acres85 ft deep · 13 fish species | 54°FOct 30 |
| Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)Webb · Herkimer County1,070 acres12 fish species | 55°FOct 30 |
| Hinckley ReservoirHinkley · Herkimer County and Oneida County2,880 acres15 fish species | 49°FOct 30 |
| Stillwater ReservoirLowville · Herkimer County6,700 acres32 ft deep · 10 fish species | 54°FOct 30 |
| Big Moose LakeWebb · Herkimer County1,242 acres14 fish species | 54°FOct 30 |
| South LakeAtwell · Herkimer County486 acres60 ft deep · 13 fish species | 54°FOct 30 |
| Nicks LakeWebb · Herkimer County206 acres17 ft deep · 8 fish species | 53°FOct 30 |
| Limekiln LakeOhio · Herkimer County457 acres70 ft deep · 12 fish species | 54°FOct 30 |
| East Canada LakeCrum Creek · Herkimer County173 acres21 ft deep | 55°FOct 30 |
| Jerseyfield LakeSalisbury · Herkimer County and Hamilton County380 acres10 fish species | 51°FOct 30 |
| Woodhull LakeWebb · Herkimer County118 acres9 fish species | 54°FOct 30 |
| First LakeAtwell · Herkimer County153 acres47 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Clear LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County106 acres60 ft deep | 52°FOct 30 |
| Falls LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County91 acres4 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Honnedaga LakeAtwell · Herkimer County825 acres124 ft deep | 55°FOct 30 |
| Gull LakeWoodgate · Herkimer County133 acres34 ft deep | 52°FOct 30 |
| Second LakeAtwell · Herkimer County119 acres32 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Weaver LakeWarren · Herkimer County100 acres11 ft deep | 52°FOct 30 |
| Spruce LakeSalisbury · Herkimer County89 acres3 ft deep | 52°FOct 30 |
| Moss LakeEagle Bay · Herkimer County121 acres45 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Black Creek LakeHoffmeister · Herkimer County79 acres64 ft deep | 52°FOct 30 |
| Kyser LakeDolgeville · Herkimer County153 acres35 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Gull LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County79 acres51 ft deep | 51°FOct 30 |
| Lyon LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County82 acres41 ft deep | 51°FOct 30 |
| Klondike ReservoirStratford · Herkimer County114 acres35 ft deep | 52°FOct 30 |
| North LakeAtwell · Herkimer County432 acres96 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
| Little Moose LakeOld Forge · Herkimer County692 acres122 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Big Otter LakeMinnehaha · Herkimer County245 acres31 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
| Canachagala LakeAtwell · Herkimer County336 acres77 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Rock LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County200 acres54 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Salmon LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County104 acres39 ft deep | 47°FOct 30 |
| Little Safford LakeOld Forge · Herkimer County91 acres13 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
| Little Woodhull LakeAtwell · Herkimer County77 acres7 ft deep | 51°FOct 30 |
| Dart LakeEagle Bay · Herkimer County141 acres35 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Moshier ReservoirWebb · Herkimer County279 acres75 ft deep | 48°FOct 30 |
| Oven LakeWanakena · Herkimer County106 acres12 ft deep | 49°FOct 30 |
| Twitchell LakeWebb · Herkimer County150 acres38 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
| Lake RondaxeOld Forge · Herkimer County249 acres37 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
| Crooked LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County133 acres52 ft deep | 48°FOct 30 |
| Sand LakeAtwell · Herkimer County314 acres83 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
| Witchhopple LakeBeaver River · Herkimer County96 acres28 ft deep | 51°FOct 30 |
| Negro LakeSabattis · Herkimer County124 acres35 ft deep | 55°FOct 30 |
| South LakeArietta · Herkimer County90 acres60 ft deep | 54°FOct 30 |
| Nelson LakeMckeever · Herkimer County74 acres40 ft deep | 53°FOct 30 |
Lakes in nearby counties
Questions about lakes in Herkimer County, New York
- How many lakes are in Herkimer County, New York?
- LakeMonster tracks 44 lakes and reservoirs in Herkimer County, New York. This counts the lakes LakeMonster follows, not every pond and water body.
- What is the largest lake in Herkimer County, New York?
- By recorded surface area, the largest lake in Herkimer County, New York on LakeMonster is Stillwater Reservoir at 6,700 acres, followed by Hinckley Reservoir (2,880 acres), Fourth Lake (2,137 acres) and Big Moose Lake (1,242 acres).
- What is the deepest lake in Herkimer County, New York?
- Of the lakes with a recorded maximum depth, the deepest is Honnedaga Lake at about 124 feet, followed by Little Moose Lake (122 ft), North Lake (96 ft) and Fourth Lake (85 ft).
- What fish can you catch in Herkimer County, New York lakes?
- The species listed most often for Herkimer County, New York lakes on LakeMonster are black crappie (10 lakes), bluegill (10 lakes), largemouth bass (10 lakes), northern pike (10 lakes), pumpkinseed (10 lakes) and smallmouth bass (10 lakes). Species lists are available for 10 of the 44 lakes. Check state regulations and seasons before fishing.
- What are the most popular lakes in Herkimer County, New York?
- The most visited Herkimer County, New York lake pages on LakeMonster are Fourth Lake, Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third), Hinckley Reservoir, Stillwater Reservoir and Big Moose Lake.
Keep exploring
This list is rebuilt every day from LakeMonster’s lake records. Newest lake data in Herkimer County, New York: . Sizes, depths and amenities are as recorded and are not available for every lake; water temperature readings show their own date.