Lake George, New York

Lakes in Herkimer County, New York

Photo: Lake George, New York. Hayden Soloviev, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

LakeMonster tracks 44 lakes and reservoirs in Herkimer County, New York, with a combined recorded surface of about 22,000 acres. The largest is Stillwater Reservoir (6,700 acres) and the most visited on LakeMonster is Fourth Lake. Fish species are listed for 10 of them, most often black crappie, bluegill and largemouth bass. Each lake page shows water temperature, lake weather and wind, satellite imagery and a map, so you can compare lakes before you drive.

Lakes
44
Recorded surface
22,000
acres of water
Fish species
17
listed across 10 lakes

Map of lakes in Herkimer County, New York

Loading the map…

 

Herkimer County, New York lakes by the numbers

Most visited on LakeMonster

  1. 1.Fourth Lake2,137 acres
  2. 2.Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)1,070 acres
  3. 3.Hinckley Reservoir2,880 acres
  4. 4.Stillwater Reservoir6,700 acres
  5. 5.Big Moose Lake1,242 acres

Largest by surface area

  1. 1.Stillwater Reservoir6,700 acres
  2. 2.Hinckley Reservoir2,880 acres
  3. 3.Fourth Lake2,137 acres
  4. 4.Big Moose Lake1,242 acres
  5. 5.Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)1,070 acres

Deepest on record

  1. 1.Honnedaga Lake124 ft
  2. 2.Little Moose Lake122 ft
  3. 3.North Lake96 ft
  4. 4.Fourth Lake85 ft
  5. 5.Sand Lake83 ft

All 44 lakes in Herkimer County, New York

Showing 1–44 of 44 lakes

ListCards
  • Satellite view of Fourth Lake

    Fourth Lake

    Inlet · Herkimer County and Hamilton County

    Size
    2,137 acres
    Max depth
    85 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Fish: Lake trout, Rainbow trout, Brown trout, Smallmouth bass and 9 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)

    Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third)

    Webb · Herkimer County

    Size
    1,070 acres
    Water temp, Oct 30
    55°F

    Fish: Largemouth bass, Smallmouth bass, Northern pike, Walleye and 8 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Hinckley Reservoir

    Hinckley Reservoir

    Hinkley · Herkimer County and Oneida County

    Size
    2,880 acres
    Elevation
    1,224 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    49°F

    Fish: Largemouth bass, Smallmouth bass, Northern pike, Walleye and 11 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Stillwater Reservoir

    Stillwater Reservoir

    Lowville · Herkimer County

    Size
    6,700 acres
    Max depth
    32 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Fish: Northern pike, Smallmouth bass, Largemouth bass, Yellow perch and 6 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Big Moose Lake

    Big Moose Lake

    Webb · Herkimer County

    Size
    1,242 acres
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Fish: Largemouth bass, Smallmouth bass, Northern pike, Yellow perch and 10 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of South Lake

    South Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    486 acres
    Max depth
    60 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Fish: Largemouth bass, Smallmouth bass, Bluegill, Pumpkinseed and 9 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Nicks Lake

    Nicks Lake

    Webb · Herkimer County

    Size
    206 acres
    Max depth
    17 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Fish: Largemouth bass, Smallmouth bass, Northern pike, Yellow perch and 4 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Limekiln Lake

    Limekiln Lake

    Ohio · Herkimer County

    Size
    457 acres
    Max depth
    70 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Fish: Brook trout, Brown trout, Lake trout, Rainbow trout and 8 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of East Canada Lake

    East Canada Lake

    Crum Creek · Herkimer County

    Size
    173 acres
    Max depth
    21 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    55°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Jerseyfield Lake

    Jerseyfield Lake

    Salisbury · Herkimer County and Hamilton County

    Size
    380 acres
    Water temp, Oct 30
    51°F

    Fish: Largemouth bass, Smallmouth bass, Northern pike, Walleye and 6 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Woodhull Lake

    Woodhull Lake

    Webb · Herkimer County

    Size
    118 acres
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Fish: Northern pike, Yellow perch, Smallmouth bass, Largemouth bass and 5 more

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of First Lake

    First Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    153 acres
    Max depth
    47 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Clear Lake

    Clear Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    106 acres
    Max depth
    60 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    52°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Falls Lake

    Falls Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    91 acres
    Max depth
    4 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Honnedaga Lake

    Honnedaga Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    825 acres
    Max depth
    124 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    55°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Gull Lake

    Gull Lake

    Woodgate · Herkimer County

    Size
    133 acres
    Max depth
    34 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    52°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Second Lake

    Second Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    119 acres
    Max depth
    32 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Weaver Lake

    Weaver Lake

    Warren · Herkimer County

    Size
    100 acres
    Max depth
    11 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    52°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Spruce Lake

    Spruce Lake

    Salisbury · Herkimer County

    Size
    89 acres
    Max depth
    3 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    52°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Moss Lake

    Moss Lake

    Eagle Bay · Herkimer County

    Size
    121 acres
    Max depth
    45 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Black Creek Lake

    Black Creek Lake

    Hoffmeister · Herkimer County

    Size
    79 acres
    Max depth
    64 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    52°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Kyser Lake

    Kyser Lake

    Dolgeville · Herkimer County

    Size
    153 acres
    Max depth
    35 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Gull Lake

    Gull Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    79 acres
    Max depth
    51 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    51°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Lyon Lake

    Lyon Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    82 acres
    Max depth
    41 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    51°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Klondike Reservoir

    Klondike Reservoir

    Stratford · Herkimer County

    Size
    114 acres
    Max depth
    35 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    52°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of North Lake

    North Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    432 acres
    Max depth
    96 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Little Moose Lake

    Little Moose Lake

    Old Forge · Herkimer County

    Size
    692 acres
    Max depth
    122 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Big Otter Lake

    Big Otter Lake

    Minnehaha · Herkimer County

    Size
    245 acres
    Max depth
    31 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Canachagala Lake

    Canachagala Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    336 acres
    Max depth
    77 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Rock Lake

    Rock Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    200 acres
    Max depth
    54 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Salmon Lake

    Salmon Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    104 acres
    Max depth
    39 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    47°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Little Safford Lake

    Little Safford Lake

    Old Forge · Herkimer County

    Size
    91 acres
    Max depth
    13 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Little Woodhull Lake

    Little Woodhull Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    77 acres
    Max depth
    7 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    51°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Dart Lake

    Dart Lake

    Eagle Bay · Herkimer County

    Size
    141 acres
    Max depth
    35 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Moshier Reservoir

    Moshier Reservoir

    Webb · Herkimer County

    Size
    279 acres
    Max depth
    75 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    48°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Oven Lake

    Oven Lake

    Wanakena · Herkimer County

    Size
    106 acres
    Max depth
    12 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    49°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Twitchell Lake

    Twitchell Lake

    Webb · Herkimer County

    Size
    150 acres
    Max depth
    38 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Lake Rondaxe

    Lake Rondaxe

    Old Forge · Herkimer County

    Size
    249 acres
    Max depth
    37 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Crooked Lake

    Crooked Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    133 acres
    Max depth
    52 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    48°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Sand Lake

    Sand Lake

    Atwell · Herkimer County

    Size
    314 acres
    Max depth
    83 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Witchhopple Lake

    Witchhopple Lake

    Beaver River · Herkimer County

    Size
    96 acres
    Max depth
    28 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    51°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Negro Lake

    Negro Lake

    Sabattis · Herkimer County

    Size
    124 acres
    Max depth
    35 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    55°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of South Lake

    South Lake

    Arietta · Herkimer County

    Size
    90 acres
    Max depth
    60 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    54°F

    Conditions, weather and map

  • Satellite view of Nelson Lake

    Nelson Lake

    Mckeever · Herkimer County

    Size
    74 acres
    Max depth
    40 ft
    Water temp, Oct 30
    53°F

    Conditions, weather and map

Lakes in nearby counties

All 584 lakes in New York

Questions about lakes in Herkimer County, New York

How many lakes are in Herkimer County, New York?
LakeMonster tracks 44 lakes and reservoirs in Herkimer County, New York. This counts the lakes LakeMonster follows, not every pond and water body.
What is the largest lake in Herkimer County, New York?
By recorded surface area, the largest lake in Herkimer County, New York on LakeMonster is Stillwater Reservoir at 6,700 acres, followed by Hinckley Reservoir (2,880 acres), Fourth Lake (2,137 acres) and Big Moose Lake (1,242 acres).
What is the deepest lake in Herkimer County, New York?
Of the lakes with a recorded maximum depth, the deepest is Honnedaga Lake at about 124 feet, followed by Little Moose Lake (122 ft), North Lake (96 ft) and Fourth Lake (85 ft).
What fish can you catch in Herkimer County, New York lakes?
The species listed most often for Herkimer County, New York lakes on LakeMonster are black crappie (10 lakes), bluegill (10 lakes), largemouth bass (10 lakes), northern pike (10 lakes), pumpkinseed (10 lakes) and smallmouth bass (10 lakes). Species lists are available for 10 of the 44 lakes. Check state regulations and seasons before fishing.
What are the most popular lakes in Herkimer County, New York?
The most visited Herkimer County, New York lake pages on LakeMonster are Fourth Lake, Fulton Chain of Lakes (First, Second, and Third), Hinckley Reservoir, Stillwater Reservoir and Big Moose Lake.

Keep exploring

This list is rebuilt every day from LakeMonster’s lake records. Newest lake data in Herkimer County, New York: . Sizes, depths and amenities are as recorded and are not available for every lake; water temperature readings show their own date.

Lakes in Herkimer County, New York: 44 Lakes & Map | LakeMonster